Your donors are the heartbeat of your nonprofit. The right donor appreciation gifts not only show your gratitude, but they establish trust, deepen loyalty, and remind supporters that their dollars are fueling real, measurable good in the world.
When you choose gifts that reflect your organization’s values, like sustainability and serving the underserved, you send a powerful message: every donor dollar creates impact. In a world full of giving options, that authenticity helps you stand out and fortify long-term donor relationships.
We’ve rounded up five of our favorite donor appreciation gifts that do good in the world and will leave a lasting impression on your supporters.
1. A Completely Custom Gift
For your most dedicated donors, create something one-of-a-kind that reflects your mission. Many of our nonprofit partners love collaborating on fully customized gifts—like the handcrafted football tray we created with the 49ers Foundation. Beyond its beauty, it represented over 600 hours of dignified work for artisans in the Petén Jungle of Guatemala. A custom piece shows your donors how deeply you value their partnership—and the positive impact that their generosity supports.
To get things rolling, just fill out our Contact Us form with some details about what you’re looking for and someone from our team will be in touch within 24-48 hours!
2. Customizable Wellness Gift Sets
Give your donors the gift of wellness—with extra meaning. Our curated boxes can be personalized to reflect the causes they care about most. Choose from items like:
- Spa products, essential oils, and lotions made by formerly trafficked women in Tennessee rebuilding their lives
- Socks that align with the causes your organization cares about most, like protecting our oceans, supporting mental health, or protecting women from abuse
- Jams, teas, and bath products that provide jobs for people transitioning out of homelessness in Santa Cruz, CA
- Fun snacks and easy-to-make baking mixes that help chronically unemployed women in Denver rebuild their lives and envision brighter futures
- Coffee that supports refugees in building skills and finding work and community in Berkeley, CA
Each item you choose nurtures your donors’ wellbeing while uplifting communities around the world.
3. Sustainable Duo: Good for People and the Planet
For eco-conscious donors, sustainability speaks volumes. This thoughtful pairing includes:
- A brandable bottle that funds the removal of 1,000 plastic bottles from the world’s most polluted waterways—with technology that continues to fund cleanups as the bottle is used
- An Upcycled Sling Bag handcrafted from materials that would otherwise end up in India’s landfills—giving waste new life and artisans new opportunity
Together, these gifts make sustainability tangible.
4. Branded Caps & Tees That Make a Statement
For donor events, volunteer appreciation, or outdoor programs, branded ethical apparel is always a hit. Each cap and t-shirt in our collection supports artisans earning dignified wages while using environmentally conscious materials. Your logo paired with their story becomes a conversation starter—and a visible reminder of your shared commitment to impact.
5. A Mug, Coffee, & Tea That Uplift the Underserved and Protect Our Planet
Pair your message of gratitude with warmth and comfort. A gift set featuring coffee supporting refugees and tea lifting up women who have been trafficked paired with a tumbler that rescues plastic from our waterways —creates a daily ritual of reflection, hope, and optimism. Every sip reminds donors of the lives they’ve touched through your organization.
As a thank you for the impact you make, 501(c)(3) organizations receive 5% off all Peace by Piece International gifts.
Whether you’re thanking a first-time donor or honoring long-term supporters, your gifts can tell a story of empowerment, sustainability, and shared purpose.
